The paper aims at approximating functions through a sequence of linear positive operators of continuous type. First we define the Appell polynomials of dimension \(d(d\geq2)\) and with their aid we expand the Sz\'{a}sz-Mirakjan operators in the Durrmeyer sense. The investigation of the new class of operators involves the study of convergence by using the universal Bohman-Korovkin theorem and the indication of the error by using modulus of smoothness. The main results are given by the asymptotic expansion of both the operators and their derivatives with the explicit specification of all coefficients in a concise form. In particular, Voronovskaja type theorems are obtained.
Authors
Ulrich Abel
Technische Hochschule Mittelhessen, Wilhelm-Leuschner-Straße 13, 61169 Friedberg, Germany
Octavian Agratini
Tiberiu Popoviciu Institute of Numerical Analysis, Romanian Academy, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
Radu Paltanea
Department of Mathematics, Transilvania University, Brasov, Romania
Keywords
Positive linear operator; Appell polynomial; Asymptotic expansion; Rate of convergence; Modulus of continuity.
Paper coordinates
U. Abel,O. Agratini, R. Păltănea, Szász–Mirakjan–Durrmeyer operators defined by multiple Appell polynomials, Positivity, 29 (2025), art. no. 17, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11117-024-01108-6
[1] Abel, U., Agratini, O., Ivan,M., Asymptotic properties of Kantorovich-type Szász-Mirakjan operators of higher order. Math. Found. Comput. 6(3), 290–302 (2023)
[2] Abel, U., Agratini, O., Paltanea, R (2018) A complete asymptotic expansion for the quasi-interpolants of Gauß-Weiertraß operators. Mediterr. J. Math. 15, 156 (2018)
[3] Agrawal, P.N., Singh, S., Stancu variant of Jakimovski-Leviatan-Durrmeyer operators involvingBrenke type polynomials. Math. Found. Comput. 7(1), 1–19 (2024)
[4] Altomare, F., Campiti, M., Korovkin-type Approximation Theory and its Applications, Walter de Gruyter Studies in Mathematics, vol. 17. de Gruyter & Co., Berlin (1994)
[5] Altomare, F., Korovkin-type theorems and approximation by positive linear operators. Surv. Approx. Theory 5, 92–164 (2010)
[6] Ansari, K.J., Mursaleen, M., Rahman, S., Approximation by Jakimovski-Leviatan operators of Durrmeyer type involving multiple Appell polynomials. RACSAM 113, 1007–1024 (2019)
[7] Appell, P.E., Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup., 3e Série. Sur une classe de polynômes 9, 119–144 (1880)
[8] Braha, N.L., Kadak, U., Approximation properties of the generalized Szasz operators by multiple Appell polynomials via power summability method. Math. Methods Appl. Sci. 43(5), 2337–2356 (2020)
[9] Gupta, P., Acu, A.M., Agrawal, P.N., Jakimovski-Leviatan operators of Kantorovich type involving multiple Appell polynomials. Georgian Math. J. 28(1), 73–82 (2021)
[10] Gupta, P., Agrawal, P.N., Quantitative Voronovskaja and Grüss Voronovskaja-Type Theorems for Operators of Kantorovich Type Involving Multiple Appell Polynomials, Iran. J. Sci. Technol. Trans. Sci. 43, 1679–1687 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40995-018-0613-x
[11] Jakimovski, A., Leviatan, D., Generalized Szász operators for the approximation in the infinite interval. Mathematica (Cluj) 11(34), 97–103 (1969)
[12] Lee, D.W., On multiple Appell polynomials. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 139(6), 2133–2141 (2011)
[13] Mazhar, S.M., Totik, V., Approximation by modified Szász operators. Acta Sci. Math. 49, 257–269 (1985)
[14] Mirakjan, G.M., Approximation of continuous functions with the aid of polynomials (Russian), C.R. (Doklady). Acad. Sci. URSS (N.S.) 31, 201–205 (1941)
[15] Nasiruzzaman, M., Convergence on sequences of Szász-Jakimovski-Leviatan type operators and related results. Math. Found. Comput. 6(2), 218–230 (2023)
[16] Nasiruzzaman, M., Aljohani, A.F., Approximation by Szász-Jakimovski-Leviatan-type operators via aid of Appell polynomials, J. Funct. Spaces, Vol. 2020, ID 9657489, 11 pages
[17] Shisha, O., Mond, B., The degree of convergence of linear positive operators. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 60, 1196–1200 (1968)
[18] Sikkema, P.C., On some linear positive operators. Indag. Math. 32, 327–337 (1970)
[19] Swarup, C., Gupta, P., Dubey, R., Mishra, V.N., Generalization of Szász-Mirakjan-Kantorovich operators using multiple Appell polynomials. J. Inequal. Appl. 2020, 156 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13660-020-02423-8
[20] Szász, O., Generalization of S. Bernstein’s polynomials to the infinite interval. J. Res. Nat. Bur. Standards 45(3), 239–245 (1950)
[21] Varma, S., On a generalization of Szász operators by multiple Appell polynomials. Stud. Univ. Babe¸sBolyai Math. 58(3), 361–369 (2013)
[22] Wood, B., Generalized Szász operators for the approximation in the complex domain. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 17(4), 790–801 (1969)
Szász-Mirakjan-Durrmeyer operators defined by multiple Appell polynomials
Ulrich Abel 1 (D) ⋅ Octavian Agratini 2 (D) ⋅ Radu Păltănea 3 (D)
Abstract
The paper aims at approximating functions through a sequence of linear positive operators of continuous type. First we define the Appell polynomials of dimension and with their aid we expand the Szász-Mirakjan operators in the Durrmeyer sense. The investigation of the new class of operators involves the study of convergence by using the universal Bohman-Korovkin theorem and the indication of the error by using modulus of smoothness. The main results are given by the asymptotic expansion of both the operators and their derivatives with the explicit specification of all coefficients in a concise form. In particular, Voronovskaja type theorems are obtained.
Keywords Positive linear operator • Appell polynomial • Asymptotic expansion • Rate of convergence • Modulus of continuity
The paper falls within the field of Approximation Theory motivated by the fact that over time the interest in the study of linear approximation processes has experienced
00footnotetext: Octavian Agratini, Radu Păltănea: contributed equally to this work.
Ulrich Abel
Ulrich.Abel@mnd.thm.de Octavian Agratini
agratini@ictp.acad.ro Radu Păltănea
radupaltanea@yahoo.com 1 MND, Technische Hochschule Mittelhessen, Wilhelm-Leuschner-Straße 13, 61169 Friedberg, Germany
2 Tiberiu Popoviciu Institute of Numerical Analysis, Romanian Academy, Street Fântânele 57, 400320 Cluj-Napoca, Romania
3 Department of Mathematics, Transilvania University, Street Eroilor 29, 500036 Braşov, Romania
a wide development. This is justified by providing an easy-to-use method of modeling signals belonging to various spaces of functions.
The published researches focused on different aspects: revealing new properties of classical positive linear operators, integral extensions of discrete operators, generalizations of these operators by introducing some parameters, or by multidimensional extensions. For an overview of this domain, Altomare and Campiti’s monograph [4] can be consulted.
The Szász-Mirakjan operators [20], [14], are among the most intensively studied positive linear operators of discrete type. In 1969 Jakimovski and Leviatan [11] presented a generalization of this approximation process involving the Appell polynomials. We recall that the sequence of polynomials introduced by Paul Émile Appell [7] satisfies the fundamental relation
(1)
being a non-zero constant.
This sequence has a generating function of the form
(2)
where is an analytic function with a power series expansion
(3)
in the disk , with . The property given in (1) is equivalent to the existence of a scalar sequence with , such that
where .
The class of these polynomials is comprehensive, containing as special cases a large number of classical sequences of polynomials. Examples, up to normalization, are the Bernoulli polynomials, the Euler polynomials, the Hermite polynomials. This is one of the reasons that paper [11] served as a starting point for numerous articles that appeared over time.
Set . Denoting by the class of functions of exponential type which satisfy the property , for some finite positive constants and , Jakimovski and Leviatan defined the operators ,
(4)
Wood [22, Theorem 2.1] proved that , are positive operators in [ ) if and only if
where are the coefficients in (3).
In the particular case , from (2) we deduce and the operators defined by (4) turn into classical Szász-Mirakjan operators.
The purpose of the present paper is to define an integral modification in Durrmeyer sense of a generalization of operators . This construction involves a multiple Appell system on a space of dimension . Our first challenge is the definition of Appell polynomials in -dimensional space. Regarding the new class of operators introduced, we investigate its approximation properties, including the complete asymptotic expansion with the explicit indication of all coefficients, also with respect to simultaneous approximation, in a concise form.
Our obtained results are integrated into the landscape of recently published publications. For confirmation we cite some papers that aim at generalizations of Jakimovski-Leviatan operators. Varma [21] studied a bidimensional extension of discrete operators . New one and two dimensional variants of these discrete operators have been studied in 2020 and 2023, see [16] and [15]. Due to the properties of Appell polynomials, they have been intensively used in different constructions of several general classes of operators. Thus, using the power summability method, a generalized class of Szasz operators was investigated in [8]. A one dimensional Durrmeyer extension of , operators involving Brenke type polynomials was approached in [3]. A similar extension with the aid of two-dimensional Appell polynomials was defined and explored by Ansari, Mursaleen and Rahman [6]. The Kantorovich type modification of Jakimovski-Leviatan operators based on Appell polynomials of dimension two was obtained, for example, in [9] and [19]. To complete the information about the operators of Kantorovich type implying multiple Appell polynomials we mention paper [10] in which the authors establish quantitative Voronovskaja and Grüss Voronovskaja-type theorems.
Finally, we mention that there are many papers that contain the expression multiple Appell polynomials in the title, the authors referring to the two-dimensional case. Consequently, our research is a substantial extension.
2 The operators
First of all we introduce useful notations to define our operators. Let be fixed. We use the following multi-index notation: for we set
. For real , the multinomial coefficient is defined as
where stands for Gamma function. We recall that the condition means that all coordinates of the vector are greater than or equal to zero. Since and represent usual operations in the vector space .
A multiple polynomial system with is called a multiple Appell system if it has a generating function of the form
(5)
where the real analytic function has a series expansion on an open set in a neighborhood of the origin, containing , given by
(6)
with .
For we rediscover the definition that appeared in several papers, for example in [12, Eqs. (2.1),(2.2)], [21, Eqs. (1.4),(1.5)], [6, Eq. (1.5)] or [9, Eq. (1.1)].
For our purposes we will impose some restrictions on the Appell system introduced above. We consider throughout the paper that the following conditions are met
(7)
Further we define the discrete -dimensional operators of Szász-JakimovskiLeviatan by the formula
(8)
whenever the right-hand side of (8) is finite.
In the special case we find the construction from [21, Eq. (1.6)], the author proving various approximation properties of the sequence. Replacing in (8) the point evaluation with the integral
(9)
we propose the following type of Durrmeyer operators
(10)
where . We denote by the space of functions to which belongs such that (10) is well defined for all .
If we consider the function , where , we get, for ,
Hence, is well defined for all , which are so large that .
Obviously, the operators are linear and due to the conditions imposed on the multiple Appell polynomials, see (7), they are also positive. This shows that is well defined for all , provided that is sufficiently large.
Remark 1 In the special case for all , based on (5) we get
and this implies . Consequently, we can write
In the one-dimensional case, these operators are exactly the classical SzászDurrmeyer operators introduced and studied by Mazhar and Totik [13]
where .
Finally, starting from , we introduce
(11)
a key function that will be used to prove our results. Relying on (6), the properties of imply that is infinitely differentiable on a one-dimensional domain that includes a compact of the form with .
3 Preliminary results
At the beginning we determine the derivatives of the multiple Appell polynomials introduced in the previous section.
Lemma 1 For the following formula
holds.
Proof For the equation is evident. Differentiating both sides of relation (5) times with respect to , we obtain
Identifying the corresponding coefficients leads us to the desired formula.
Remark 2 From Lemma 1 it follows implicitly that if .
Let , denote the monomials defined by . For technical reasons we consider in the following the slightly more general auxiliary operators , given by
(12)
where is defined as in (9) and , where is the space of functions for which is well defined for all . As in the special case , it can be seen that is well defined for all , provided that is sufficiently large.
Obviously, we have .
Lemma 2 For each and belonging to , the moments of the operators are given by
(13)
Proof Examining relation (9), we notice that for any we can write
Hence, using relations (5) and (12), we get
Application of the Leibniz rule for differentiation yields the relation (13).
The next step is to express the central moments of the auxiliary operator . For each real number , we define the function by .
Lemma 3 For each , the central moment of order s of the operator is given by
(14)
Proof Since , by (13) we have
Using the binomial identity and index change replacing with , we obtain
Further, we apply Leibniz rule to the product.
Also, involving the Kronecker delta symbol, we observe that
Assembling the results, we obtain relation (14).
4 Main results
We highlight some global and local approximation properties of , operators. Using Lemma 2 and knowing that , see (11), through a direct calculation, we obtain the first three moments of the operators namely
Also, applying Lemma 3 and the above three identities, the central moments of order , are given as follows
(15)
Clearly, we get
(16)
However, we cannot apply the classical Korovkin theorem to obtain the uniform approximation on compacts of functions from the space ( ) by the sequence of
operators , because the interval is not compact. It is only locally compact. For this we will appeal to the following Korovkin-type theorem of Altomare [5, Theorem 3.5]. Using the notations given there, this theorem reads as follows.
Theorem A Let ( ) be a locally compact metric space and consider a lattice subspace of containing the constant function and all the functions . Let be a sequence of positive linear operators from into and assume that
(i) , uniformly on compact subsets of ;
(ii) , uniformly on compact subsets of .
Then, for every , uniformly on compact subsets of .
In this theorem, denotes the space of real functions defined on denotes the constant function equal to denotes the function and denotes the space of real continuous bounded functions defined on .
We also need of the following limit, which follows immediately from (15):
(17)
We denote by the Banach lattice of all real-valued continuous and bounded functions on , endowed with the sup-norm . If is a compact interval, the same norm is valid in the space .
Remark3 For each maps continuously into itself. This means that . For , we have , and based on the value of we deduce .
Theorem 1 Let the operators , be defined by (10). For any compact interval , the following relation
(18)
occurs, provided .
Proof We can apply the theorem of Altomare, given above, with the following choices: , and .
We take into account that .
The rate of convergence is established by using modulus of continuity defined for a function by
if this supremum is finite.
Denote by the space of locally integrable functions for which , for all . It is immediate that and , where is the space of uniformly continuous functions on .
Remark 4 Operators , are well defined on . Indeed, if , then , for . It follows that the series of the absolute values of the terms of series (10) is bounded by .
Theorem 2 Let the operators , be defined by (10). For any function , we have
where .
Proof We use the following property proved by Shisha and Mond [17, Theorem 1] that says: if is a linear positive operator, then one has
for every continuous function and . We mention that in order to fulfill the condition , the original relation was given for continuous functions defined on a compact. The proof of the Shisha and Mond theorem can be extended without any difficulty to space
Considering , using the following two identities, and (15) and finally choosing , we arrive at the stated relation.
Corollary 3 For any we have
Proof We take into account that and hence Theorem 2 can be applied. Also, because , we have
uniformly if being a compact subset of .
Note that the result in this Corollary cannot be compared with the result in Theorem 1 , because the spaces and are not comparable.
The following result concerns the asymptotic expansion of the operators. To achieve this we require certain conditions to be satisfied by the function , these being similar to those appearing in Sikkema’s paper [18, Definition]. For and , let denote the functions possessing the properties: is times differentiable at is bounded on every bounded interval of the domain and as . Moreover, we assume that all are locally integrable on .
Theorem 4 Let the operators , be defined by (12). Given and , the asymptotic relation
(19)
holds, where the coefficients are given by
(20)
Proof In particular Lemma 3 guarantees
Following Lemma 3 and Sikkema’s result, [18, Theorem 3], we infer that
with
Noting that
and changing , we get
by the Leibniz rule for differentiation.
Since , it results and the proof is completed.
For the theorem includes the asymptotic expansion of the operators defined at (10).
For the convenience of the reader we present explicitly the first three coefficients.
(21)
Also, based on (19) and (20), a result of Voronovskaja type will have the following form.
Corollary 5 Given and , the operators satisfy the asymptotic relation
Another special case arises if we consider a (locally) very smooth function.
Corollary 6 Let . If is of at most polynomial growth and infinitely differentiable at , then the operators possess the complete pointwise asymptotic expansion
We mention that a similar approach was carried out both in [1, Theorem 3.1] with reference to Kantorovich-Szász-Mirakjan operators of higher order and in [2, Theorem 1.1] for the quasi-interpolants of Gauss-Weierstrass operators.
Further, we focus on the simultaneous approximation by our linear positive operators. At first step we represent the derivatives of as a finite linear combination of the auxiliary operators .
Theorem 7 For any , the following identity
(22)
holds for and .
Proof For , the formula is evident. Fixing arbitrarily , from (10) we have
(23)
As a consequence of Lemma 1 we obtain
We can write
(24)
Since
using (24) in (23), we obtain
.
Taking in view (12), the above identity becomes the relation stated at (22) and the proof is finished.
Our last step is to obtain an asymptotic expansion of operators, , under certain conditions satisfied by the function . It turns out that the expansion given in Theorem 4, for , can be differentiated term-by-term.
Theorem 8 Let the operators , be defined by (10). Let and . For any the following relation
holds, where as defined in (20).
Proof Successively using relations (22), (19) and recalling that
we can write
(25)
Further, we have
(26)
In the above, we successively applied the relation (20), the elementary identity
and the formula
Since
mixing relations (26) and (25) we infer
Applying in (20), for we easily obtain
and
The convention , concludes the proof.
Corollary 9 Let . If has at most polynomial growth and is infinitely differentiable at , then for any , the complete pointwise asymptotic expansion
is valid.
5 Conclusion
Positive linear operators play an important role in constructive approximation and have many applications. In retrospect, the paper brings important achievements in the
Approximation Theory. First of all we refer to the definition of the Appell polynomials of dimension . Based on them, the integral form in the Durrmeyer sense of the extension of the Szász-Mirakjan-Leviatan type operators leads to a new class of operators whose approximation properties are revealed. Another major achievement of the new approximation process are the asymptotic expansions of this class and its derivatives, all coefficients being explicitly calculated. Voronovskaja-type formulas become immediate consequences of these asymptotic expansions.
Abel, U., Agratini, O.: Păltănea, R (2018) A complete asymptotic expansion for the quasi-interpolants of Gauß-Weiertraß operators. Mediterr. J. Math. 15, 156 (2018)
3.
Agrawal, P.N., Singh, S.: Stancu variant of Jakimovski-Leviatan-Durrmeyer operators involving Brenke type polynomials. Math. Found. Comput. 7(1), 1-19 (2024)
4.
Altomare, F., Campiti, M.: Korovkin-type Approximation Theory and its Applications, Walter de Gruyter Studies in Mathematics, vol. 17. de Gruyter & Co., Berlin (1994)
5.
Altomare, F.: Korovkin-type theorems and approximation by positive linear operators. Surv. Approx. Theory 5, 92-164 (2010)
6.
Ansari, K.J., Mursaleen, M., Rahman, S.: Approximation by Jakimovski-Leviatan operators of Durrmeyer type involving multiple Appell polynomials. RACSAM 113, 1007-1024 (2019)
7.
Appell, P.E.: Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup., 3e Série. Sur une classe de polynômes 9, 119-144 (1880)
8.
Braha, N.L., Kadak, U.: Approximation properties of the generalized Szasz operators by multiple Appell polynomials via power summability method. Math. Methods Appl. Sci. 43(5), 2337-2356 (2020)
9.
Gupta, P., Acu, A.M., Agrawal, P.N.: Jakimovski-Leviatan operators of Kantorovich type involving multiple Appell polynomials. Georgian Math. J. 28(1), 73-82 (2021)
10.
Gupta, P., Agrawal, P.N.: Quantitative Voronovskaja and Grüss Voronovskaja-Type Theorems for Operators of Kantorovich Type Involving Multiple Appell Polynomials, Iran. J. Sci. Technol. Trans. Sci. 43, 1679-1687 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40995-018-0613-x
11.
Jakimovski, A., Leviatan, D.: Generalized Szász operators for the approximation in the infinite interval. Mathematica (Cluj) 11(34), 97-103 (1969)
12.
Lee, D.W.: On multiple Appell polynomials. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 139(6), 2133-2141 (2011)
13.
Mazhar, S.M., Totik, V.: Approximation by modified Szász operators. Acta Sci. Math. 49, 257-269 (1985)
14.
Mirakjan, G.M.: Approximation of continuous functions with the aid of polynomials (Russian), C.R. (Doklady). Acad. Sci. URSS (N.S.) 31, 201-205 (1941)
15.
Nasiruzzaman, M.: Convergence on sequences of Szász-Jakimovski-Leviatan type operators and related results. Math. Found. Comput. 6(2), 218-230 (2023)
16.
Nasiruzzaman, M., Aljohani, A.F.: Approximation by Szász-Jakimovski-Leviatan-type operators via aid of Appell polynomials, J. Funct. Spaces, Vol. 2020, ID 9657489, 11 pages
17.
Shisha, O., Mond, B.: The degree of convergence of linear positive operators. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 60, 1196-1200 (1968)
18.
Sikkema, P.C.: On some linear positive operators. Indag. Math. 32, 327-337 (1970)
19.
Swarup, C., Gupta, P., Dubey, R., Mishra, V.N.: Generalization of Szász-Mirakjan-Kantorovich operators using multiple Appell polynomials. J. Inequal. Appl. 2020, 156 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/ s13660-020-02423-8
20.
Szász, O.: Generalization of S. Bernstein’s polynomials to the infinite interval. J. Res. Nat. Bur. Standards 45(3), 239-245 (1950)
21.
Varma, S.: On a generalization of Szász operators by multiple Appell polynomials. Stud. Univ. BabeşBolyai Math. 58(3), 361-369 (2013)
22.
Wood, B.: Generalized Szász operators for the approximation in the complex domain. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 17(4), 790-801 (1969)